Welcome to Sunday’s Idea Brunch, your interview series with great off-the-beaten-path investors. We are very excited to interview Ahmed Tabaqchali!
Ahmed is currently Chief Strategist of Asia Frontier Capital’s Iraq Fund and is a capital markets professional with over 30 years of experience in US and MENA markets. Before AFC, he was an Executive Director at NBK Capital, the investment banking arm of the National Bank of Kuwait, and held senior institutional sales roles at WR Hambrecht + Co., KeyBanc, Jefferies International, and Dean Witter International. He is a board member of Arab Bank Iraq, and of Iraq Fund for Higher Education (IFHE)/Baghdad Business School (BBS). He is also a non-resident Senior Fellow at the Atlantic Council, and a Senior Fellow at the Institute of Regional and International Studies (IRIS) at the American University of Iraq-Sulaimani (AUIS).
This interview was conducted with help from Sam Wilkins.
Ahmed, thanks for doing Sunday’s Idea Brunch! Can you tell readers a little about your background and the trajectory that led you to investments in Iraq and the AFC Iraq Fund?
Thank you for the invitation and for the opportunity to discuss the AFC Iraq Fund and the Iraq Investment story… You cannot get more off the beaten track than you would with Iraq, whether it’s an off-the-beaten-track travel experience of 5,000 years of human history, the birthplace of writing, literature, and urban civilization; or an off-the-beaten-track investment opportunity in one of the last ultimate frontier markets that has the potential to become a major regional market.
The old Iraqi oral folklore phrase “من يشرب من ماء دجلة لا بد أن يعود إليه” or “Whoever drinks the water of the Tigris is bound to return to it” aptly describes the trajectory that led me to the AFC Iraq Fund. I left Baghdad in 1976/77, as a teenager, and met my AFC colleague, Ruchir Desai, upon my return about 37 years later in Erbil in 2013. Ruchir was attending an Iraq investor conference, as part of AFC on-the-ground investing, and I was working as part of an advisory team on an IPO of one of Iraq’s three major mobile operators. Soon afterward, I met my partner and friend Thomas in London a number of times over the year, and we teamed up to launch the AFC Iraq Fund in June/July 2014 within a few weeks of the fall of Mosul to ISIS a few months earlier. Given the extent of the extremely negative news coverage and predictions of the end of Iraq, I was convinced that the time was right for launching such a fund, and Thomas agreed wholeheartedly – a year later, the AFC Iraq Fund was launched in June 2015.
However, a great deal has happened in between that has shaped me as a person, and crucially is relevant to the AFC Iraq Fund – in terms of the investment thesis and its follow-through. As a son of a career diplomat, I lived and studied all over the world from New Zealand, Far East Asia, the Middle East, including Northern Africa, and to Western Europe with my academic qualifications attesting to this diversity –primary and intermediate school Baccalaureates from Iraq, high school Baccalaureate from Algeria, GCSE “A” levels in the UK, two Bachelor degrees in New Zealand, and finally a master’s degree in the UK. My late father instilled in me from a young age the attitude best encapsulated by “In Rome, do as the Romans do”, and as such I immersed myself in all the wonderful cultures that I lived in, and have always been at home in all the places that I lived in –in fact, when I think of home, it’s both Iraq and the UK (in alphabetical order).
I started my career as an institutional stockbroker working for US investment banks based in London, servicing UK and European institutional investors on US investments. However, I wasn’t a typical institutional broker, in that I conducted my own research, especially in technology (starting in the 1990s, before investing in technology was a thing !!!), but broadened it to include other market sectors and commodities. As my understanding of markets grew. Working in US markets from the early 1990s shaped my understanding of economics, markets, and investments across the equity market spectrum -spanning micro-caps to large caps, market sectors, as well as trading of securities on the different US exchanges, including working in risk arbitrage and portfolio trading. After which I went to the GCC, first in the UAE and then in Kuwait, and worked on Index and ETF creation, retail, high net worth, and institutional research and brokerage in the GCC markets, as well as in Egypt. These experiences played, and continue to play a crucial role in shaping the AFC Iraq Fund’s investment thesis and its execution – for instance, stock vs company, market structure, bid-offer spreads, level of institutional flows, investor base, level of foreign versus domestic investors, as well as political risk that is key to investing in the Middle East. All of these are extremely relevant to understanding and investing (both the process of stock selection and the mechanics of trading, including building and exiting positions), as well as cash management in a young, shallow market like Iraq that has the potential to be among the largest in the Middle East.
You’ve called Iraq an “anomaly” in the Middle East. Can you tell us what you mean by that?
In the region, Iraq is a market anomaly with significant upside potential if conditions normalize. On so many levels, it has major-league firepower, yet its plays in the minor leagues in so many of them. This is more so when one considers its superior (vis-à-vis its neighbors) upside potential as a function of geographic and natural resource wealth in the post-Strait of Hormuz world – as outlined in “Oil Deals Galore and a Diminishing Perceived Risk Premium”
In oil, its reserves and production potential are second only to Saudi Arabia, yet its stock market (as a function of its economic transformation) has not been transformed as Saudi Arabia’s stock market had – in both absolute terms, and a percentage of GDP, its stock market is a fraction of its neighbors, including the non-oil producing countries. Even a partial catch-up, should conditions begin to normalize, would see its market capitalization double or triple at least – granted a big if, but possible.
Unlike many countries in the region that either have a large population or large oil wealth, Iraq has both – among the top oil reserves in the world, a large population estimated at 46 million in 2026 that is projected to reach 72 million by 2050. The youth are a big feature of its current and future population profile, as its population is broad at the base, i.e., an expansive population pyramid.
Thus, its domestic market alone can support its industries/businesses for decades to come, given the catch-up opportunities of decades of conflict that laid waste to its capital and infrastructure (physical and human). For example, its real estate market is booming, reflecting unmet current, let alone future, demand for housing/accommodation. For example, I left Baghdad as a teenager in the late 70s when its population was about 3 million, while its population is estimated at 8 million in 2026, with the larger metropolitan area estimated at about 11 million. Yet its housing infrastructure in 2017, when I began to move there, massively lagged this population growth, let alone future growth. It’s no wonder that its real estate market is booming, with houses and buildings demolished daily to be replaced by towers. Interestingly, the mortgage market is in its infancy, but some banks are begging to respond to this opportunity.
I could go on and on about so many sectors, especially the potential of its tourism sector and its spillover effects on the economy, given its rich heritage. As Gerard Russel writes in his book “Heirs to Forgotten Kingdoms: In the landscape of recorded history, Iraq is Everest: just as Everest makes other mountains seem small, Iraq makes even ancient history seem recent by comparison.” But I will stop here.
You have written before about the difference between perceived risk and actual risk in investing in Iraq. Do you think this is expanding or contracting? How do you communicate to your investors that real risk is still high, while maintaining that it isn’t as high as they may think?
On the surface, the difference, or delta, between the two is still very high, as can be seen from the early coverage of the Iran war and the closure of the Strait of Hormuz – which effectively shut off 95% of Iraq’s oil exports. Almost all coverage was of the devastating consequences on Iraq’s economy from such a loss, and so, not for the first time, the country’s obituary was being prepared – compounding the gloom were voices within Iraq, in the person of the foreign minister, who warned of “financial catastrophe” if the war continues. In the meantime, life continued as normal in Iraq.
Beneath the surface, the picture is mixed. For starters, investment interest, as pointed out in a response to an earlier question, is almost non-existent, and so here the gap is still very wide. However, in the real economy, things are different in that companies from regional countries such as Jordan and Egypt, but not the GCC, have been heading to Iraq, and following them, their employees. Most of the time, I fly to Baghdad from London through Amman, or just from Amman, via Royal Jordanian, which flies about 3 daily flights between Amman and Baghdad, and most of these are almost full in both economy and business class. I am told the same is true of flights from Dubai and other regional capitals. Foreigners are far more visible in Baghdad, either as visitors or employees of regional companies. Jordanian banks, some of which were present in Iraq for years through stakes in major Iraqi banks, are investing and focusing on Iraq, attracted by the development of its banking industry over the last few years– either through new Iraqi set-up banks like Arab Bank Iraq (set up as an Iraqi company, with majority ownership by Arab Bank; plus I should note that I was invited to join the board of Arab Bank Iraq when it was set up), or setting up branches. For Egyptian firms, Iraq has become the top destination for their corporate investments abroad, with firms spanning real estate development (a sector that is booming in Iraq driven by decades of underinvestment, and so the gap between demand and supply is massive, and is growing due to population growth), and supporting industries like construction, civil engineering and so on; plus, another major sector is in Fast-Moving Consumer Goods (FMG), attracted by the high consumption of Iraqis. I should add that many other regional firms are doing the same as Egyptian and Jordanian companies (i.e., from Türkiye, Lebanon, … etc).
The main point to highlight is that companies in these countries are familiar with the risks and challenges of operating in frontier markets, as well as being familiar with the region’s political risks – and so for them arbitraging of the delta between perceived risk and real risk provides significant opportunities; and so the delta is narrowing here.
I expect that one of the consequences of the oil-focused deals, especially pipelines, is that more and more international companies will be doing the same as part of these projects’ build-up, but also on the economic opportunities from the build-up. Such developments are bound to lead up to investor demand for Iraq – as happened elsewhere in frontier and emerging markets.
For me, the communication mode of the interplay between perceived risk and real risk is not to understate the former nor overstate the latter, but to provide coverage of living and travel experience in Iraq, like what my colleague Thomas and I did on our tour of Baghdad and southern Iraq, marking the AFC Fund’s 10-year anniversary. Plus, I frequently include a section on being in Baghdad during market reports or writing market reports with a focus on developments in Iraq and so. The aim has been and continues to be showing what the country is like.
Can you please tell us about your research process and your favorite ideas or themes today?
My investment process, given the current state of Iraq’s economic development, is by necessity top-down that starts by identifying the forces driving the transformation of its economy, understanding them, and then focusing on the best companies that are well positioned to benefit/ride this transformation. This is coupled with understanding the mechanics of building positions in the portfolio and ultimately exiting them.
Of the 100+ listed companies on the ISX, about 10 can be owned by institutional investors due to float and both stock and market liquidity. The nature of being an open-ended fund, even with our funds’ two share classes of 3 and 6 months’ notice, a key consideration for me, is the ability of being able to exit a stock or a position in a stock, should I have a large redemption, with minimum effect on the price of the stock and the market –and thus on the portfolio and other investors in the fund. The same holds for building positions in stocks.
Plus, not all sectors of the economy are represented in the stock market, which limits stock ideas and favored sectors. However, in our case, the banking sector, is the area that I am most bullish on, and that is well represented in the stock market. Our investment thesis for the banking sector was outlined in early 2022 in “Banks & the Iraq Investment Thesis”. The thrust of the argument is “The investment thesis for banks is based on the opportunity for the group to grow earnings multiple times from current levels as the country moves towards a full adoption of banking and away from the dominance of cash as both a store of value and a means of economic exchange. The key element in the economy’s adoption of banking is the growth in bank lending, resulting in an expansion in the money circulating in the economy (i.e., broad money), and consequently an increase in non-oil GDP. Over time, as banks’ earnings grow substantially, this should lead to meaningful increases in their valuations.” The thesis got a significant boost later in 2022 by a potent combination of recent fundamental and technical developments that promises to accelerate the adoption of banking and bring about a transformation of the sector and its role in the economy. Such a transformation should lead to sustainable, strong earnings growth, particularly for the top-quality banks, as outlined in “Banks End a Second Year with a Bang”.
From the first investments in the AFC Iraq Fund in mid-2015, we (working closely with my partner and friend Thomas Hugger), started building the banking sector’s positions by picking up the best positioned banks. Over time, following the performance of each of the banks (fundamental), we concentrated in three names that we know have executed their strategies effectively, and believe are able to ride the banking adoption wave over the next few years (a wave is multiple years, at least over a decade in the making). Other names could join these three either by significantly expanding their weights in the portfolio or as new entrants. The three names are: the Bank of Baghdad (BBOB), the National Bank of Iraq (BNOI), and Mansour Bank (BMNS). All successfully rode the wave of 2022 that led to the acceleration in the adoption of banking, as can be seen from this table:
